Published: Wed, September 06, 2017
World | By Lorena Waters

Update: First Round of Testimony from Vides-Casanova | CJA

Update: First Round of Testimony from Vides-Casanova | CJA

By Carolyn Patty Blum, Senior Legal Advisor, Center for Justice & amp; Accountability

As reported on April 18, 2011, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has sought to remove Vides-Casanova on charges of assisting or otherwise participating in torture. See Immigration and Nationality Act § 237 (a) (4) (D), 8 U.S.C. § 1227 (a) (4) (D) (2006), referring to INA § 212 (a) (3) (E) (iii) (I), 8 U.S.C. § 1182 (a) (3) (E) (iii) (I). The removal hearing began on April 18, 2011 in Orlando, Florida, with the DHS calling its first witness: Robert White, US Ambassador to El Salvador from March 1980 to early 1981. White gave Immigration Judge James Grim a flavor of El Salvador at the time. Bodies were visible in the streets, and, in December, they watched the remains of the assassinated four US churchwomen were being exhumed from a shallow grave. During his tenure, White met numerous times with Vides-Casanova, then Director of the National Guard, to discuss putting an end to human rights abuses.

Vides Casanova's lawyer, Diego Handel, attempted to develop the counter- Narrative through White's cross-examination: US support gave the Salvadoran military an implicit "green light" to stop the Salvadoran opposition, by any means necessary. But White stressed that in reality, U.S. policy was to the contrary. "Had a political solution been pursued by El Salvador in 1980, as I and the U.S. Government recommended, ten years of conflict could have been avoided."

Dr. Juan Romagoza, CJA's lead plaintiff in the Alien Tort Statute (ATS) case against Vides, also testified (See Romagoza et al. V. Garcia and Vides-Casanova). Dr. Romagoza provided medical care at community clinics in rural El Salvador. On December 12, 1980, the residents were lining up at a church for medical consultations, troops from the Army and National Guard, accompanied by men in plain clothes, arrived. The military opened fire, wounding Juan and others. Juan was captured and eventually transported to National Guard Headquarters in San Salvador, where he was held for several weeks and tortured. At one point, Vides Casanova entered Juan's cell during a torture session. And Vides was present when Juan was released, emaciated and struggling to walk.

On cross, Vides' lawyer Diego Handel focused on minor discrepancies between Juan's testimony in the ATS case and the removal case. But he scored no points with Judge Grim who stepped in to question John personally for clarification. Handel also attempted to undermine Juan's identification of Vides in his cell. Juan had been chained to a cement floor, cleaned the day before for the visit of the "boss." According to Juan, his captors' blows had loosened his blindfold, and he was able to see Vides from the lower portion of his face on down. He also recognized Vides' voice.

DHS also called Terry Karl, a political science professor at Stanford University, as an expert witness. Professor Karl described El Salvador's long history of military control and the 1979 coup, intended to be a progressive turn, but which ultimately ended with hard-line military officers, such as Vides Casanova, gaining power. Vides and other right wing military officials ascribed to a theory of "total war," which targeted teachers, doctors, members of opposition organizations, labor leaders and the like for assassination and disappearance.

In Professor Karl's opinion, Vides pattern of conduct,Äîhis promotion and protection of known human rights abusers, failure to inspect and close down torture chambers, obstruction of investigations, refusal to dismantle death squads, and personal visitation of prisoners undergoing Torture,Äîconstituted active participation in torture.

Pentandra photos on Flickr | Flickr
Chev. • Ceiba occidentalis (Spreng.) Burkill • Ceiba thonningii A. Chev. • Eriodendron anfractuosum DC. • Eriodendron caribaeum G. Chev. • Ceiba guineensis (Schum. & Thonn.) A.

15 different uses for cardboard rolls & bull; My Sweet Things
So what can we do with them instead of throwing them? Here you can find some ideas. 1. You can follow me on FACEBOOK, PINTEREST, INSTAGRAM, TWITTER, + GOOGLE.

It's the Time to Plant Cold Weather Vegetables - The Denver Post
Motivated by the shelves full of seeds that suddenly appeared two weeks ago, I looked with pity on the state of my garden. Before planting, you should wait until the soil is completely unfrozen, but that excuse is only for a little more sleep .

On cross, Handel asked Karl to comment on passages from US State Department Country Reports from 1983 onward that were favorable to Vides. He focused on the U.S. military presence in El Salvador and read the U.S. certification of military aid prepared for Congress. But Karl reiterated Ambassador White, assertions that U.S. military training and support failed to stop human rights abuses. On redirect, she stressed that funding requests for aid to El Salvador formed a backdrop to the language of the DOS Country Reports and, consequently, qualified reliance on the reports.

At the end of the government, the case moved, the defendant moved to terminate, arguing the government lacked reliable evidence. Handel further argued that Schneider v. Kissinger , 412 F.3d 190 (D.C. Cir. 2005), the tort case dismissed on political grounds question, required dismissal of the government, removals case. The judge temporarily denied the motion, deferring to final decision until the end of the proceedings.

And so, Vides called his first witness: David Passage, former acting US Ambassador to El Salvador from mid-1984 to 1986 According to Passage, El Salvador saw dramatic improvements during his tenure. He said that Vides was receptive to change and expressed concern for human rights. However, after a contentious exchange over Passage, a qualification as an expert, Judge Grim ruled that Vides, lawyer had failed to establish his expertise. Passage was limited to testifying on information within his personal knowledge during his two years in country.

Vides next called Ambassador Edwin Corr, who explained that he was brought to El Salvador to "clean the place up." He emphasized his good relationship with Casanova Vides during his posting from 1985-1988. Corr said that the alleged decrease in human rights violations in the second half of the 1980s was a result of the U.S. emphasis on a new counter-insurgency strategy. Human rights violations needed to be reduced, I explained, because they only aided the guerillas.

With that, the hearing adjourned. The government's cross-examination of Ambassador Corr has been deferred to the continued trial date of May 24-26. At that time, Vides is expected to take the stand. Stay posted for more coverage.

Like this: